Box Office

(262) 782-4430

History of Sunset Playhouse

The history of the Playhouse is a story of friendship, camaraderie, joy, hard work, and perseverance. Since its first production of THE TURN OF THE SCREW, the Playhouse has been blessed with the contribution of 1,402,050 hours of dedicated service from 36,850 extraordinary volunteers.

 Sunset Playhouseis a not-for-profit community theater organization, incorporated in 1954. In the 1950s, a small theater group from St. Mary’s Church in Elm Grove had been leading a transitory life, performing in different venues. A building fund drive was launched, enlisting the support of the entire metropolitan Milwaukee area. Eventually the theater group managed to buy swampy land, on which stood an old barn. The newly constructed Sunset Playhouse opened its doors in March of 1960.

Click HERE to view our Production History

Sunset was the first theater in the state of Wisconsin to be built entirely by a community theater group, but the founders of the Playhouse didn’t have enough money to build the facility of their dreams.

While the structure was little more than a concrete box, it was the ticket to providing the levels of quality and service the community deserved. Without having to worry about conflicting with school events or janitor schedules, the new group’s new home would quickly become the bedrock upon which the Playhouse would continue to grow and attract thousands of volunteers.

With four additions over forty years, the Playhouse has come a long way since those early productions when the audience sat on folding chairs. A 1968 addition expanded the lobby, allowing the business office to move out of the basement. In 1973, the scene shop was able to move upstairs, with a large furniture and prop storage room below. The lobby and offices grew again in 1981 and then,


in 1999, with the biggest undertaking since the construction of the original building, a Studio Theatre was added, along with a new rehearsal hall, dressing rooms, catering kitchen, and a completely rebuilt and expanded lobby.

Over the past 60 years, Sunset has benefitted from the leadership of Ian Dobbie, Alan Furlan, Michael Spicer, Thomas Somerville, Michael Duncan, Mark Salentine, Jonathan West, Diana Alioto, and our current Artistic Director, Nancy Visintainer-Armstrong. The theater’s staff consists of an Education Director, Technical Director, Business Manager/Volunteer Coordinator, Administrative Assistant, Box Office Manager, Box Office Associates, and Theater Technicians. In addition, Sunset benefits from a large pool of talented and dedicated volunteers who work in conjunction with these professionals and are essential to the on-going success of the Playhouse. Sunset is governed by a Board of Directors elected by the membership.

Sunset produces eight Furlan Auditorium Productions per season consisting of comedies, mysteries, musicals, and dramas. The Playhouse is also home to three professional series–Musical MainStage Concert Series, with six concerts each season, a six-show cabaret series titled SideNotes Cabaret Series, and a three-show children’s series called bug in a rug.

Click HERE to view a video on the history of Sunset Playhouse featuring John Dolphin and Mary Furlan.


Click below to view our Annual Reports

2013 – 2014 Annual Report 

2014 – 2015 Annual Report 

2015 – 2016 Annual Report

2016 – 2017 Annual Report

2017 – 2018 Annual Report

2018 – 2019 Annual Report

2021-2022 Annual Report

2022-2023 Annual Report